What fails on a screen first?
The mesh fails before the frame does, almost every time. Fibreglass mesh chalks and loses tensile strength under ultraviolet light, then tears at the spline groove where it is pinched. Pet claws start a run at a corner that turns into a full tear within a season. Aluminium mesh lasts longer outdoors but dents and creases, and once creased it will not sit flat again. The spline itself, the vinyl cord that holds the mesh in the groove, hardens and shrinks with sun exposure, so the mesh sags and pulls out of the channel. The frame is usually fine: aluminium extrusions do not rot, and a bent frame can normally be straightened. That is why screen work is measured in mesh and spline rather than in whole new screens.
Can a screen be re-meshed in place or does it come out?
Most screens come out of the track and go onto a bench, because re-meshing needs a flat surface and steady tension across the whole frame. The old spline is pulled, the old mesh removed, the groove cleaned of grit and old vinyl, and the new mesh laid over the frame. It is tensioned from one corner diagonally, then the opposite corner, and the spline is rolled into the groove with a convex roller so the mesh locks without cutting. A screen that is re-meshed flat and even sits in its track and does not whistle in the wind. Doing it with the frame still hung in the window almost always produces a wavy, slack result that pulls out again within weeks.
Which mesh should go back in?
The choice is driven by what the screen has to do. Standard fibreglass is the economical option and is fine for most bedroom and living-room windows, but it does not stop a determined pet. Pet-resistant mesh uses a heavier weave and a thicker strand, and it is worth the difference where a dog or cat is pushing at the same corner repeatedly. Aluminium mesh is more durable against physical damage but blocks more light and dents permanently. Solar or privacy mesh cuts heat and glare, which matters on west-facing windows, at the cost of a darker room. The honest answer depends on which window it is and what has been breaking, not on a single product recommendation.
Why do sliding screen doors fail differently?
A sliding screen door carries its own rollers and slides in its own track, so it has more in common with a sliding glass door than with a fixed window screen. The roller wears, the track fills with grit, and the frame slowly goes out of square as the door is dragged rather than lifted. Re-meshing a slider without addressing the rollers and the track means the new mesh is dragged out of shape in the same way the old one was. The correct sequence is to free the door, service the rollers and track, re-mesh on the bench, then re-hang and adjust so the door glides without a lift at the leading edge.
Get a written figure for this job
Screen work is quoted from frame condition, mesh type and how many panels are involved, with the rollers and track included on sliding doors. Tell us which screens have failed and whether a pet or a door is behind it, and the right mesh can be agreed before the visit.
When is a new screen the better answer?
A new screen is cheaper than a repair when the frame itself has failed: a welded corner that has separated, a frame that is bent beyond straightening, or a custom size that no longer matches the opening after a window replacement. It is also the sensible route where the existing screen is a lightweight builder-grade frame on a door that gets heavy use, because re-meshing a frame that is already flexing just postpones the same failure. On a window screen with a sound aluminium frame, re-meshing is almost always the cheaper and better result, and it keeps the original fit in the track.
Why do screens in coastal air fail faster?
Salt and humidity change the failure pattern. Vinyl spline takes up moisture and hardens faster, the aluminium frame oxidises at the corners where the finish is thinnest, and stainless or aluminium mesh corrodes at cut edges. Screens on the windward side of a property age quicker than those in shelter, and screens shaded by an eave last longer than the same mesh on an exposed elevation. That is why two screens bought together can be in completely different condition. Checking the frame for corrosion at the corners before re-meshing is worth doing, because a frame that has oxidised through at a corner will not hold the spline tension even with new mesh, and the honest answer at that point is a new frame.
How should screens be looked after between repairs?
A minute of care extends screen life noticeably. Rinse with a garden hose rather than scrubbing with a brush, because scrubbing pushes grit into the weave and abrades it. Avoid pressure washing, which drives water past the spline and can tear mesh outright. Where a screen is on a door that a pet uses, a pet-resistant mesh and a well-tensioned spline are worth more than any spray or coating. Keep the track clear of grit so the screen slides rather than drags, since a screen that has to be lifted and forced tears at the corners first. And a small tear is worth addressing early: mesh fails from an edge, so a two-inch tear becomes a full re-mesh within a season.
Common questions
Can a torn screen be patched instead of re-meshed?
A patch holds for a while on a small hole in a low-traffic window, but it looks like a patch and it fails at its own edges. On a screen that a pet is pushing at, or one in a door, re-meshing the whole frame is the only result that lasts.
Does re-meshing include new spline?
Yes. Old spline is hardened and shrunk, which is usually why the mesh sagged in the first place, so new spline goes in with new mesh. Reusing the old cord is how a re-mesh ends up loose within a month.
Can you match the mesh that is already on the house?
In most cases yes, in both colour and weave, so a repaired screen does not stand out from the ones beside it. Where the existing mesh is a discontinued colour, the closest current match is offered rather than fitted without asking.
Are sliding screen door repairs done on site or in a shop?
The door comes off and is re-meshed on site, with the rollers and track serviced at the same time, then re-hung and adjusted. Nothing is taken away, so there is no period with an open doorway.